« Lorna's Laces scheming | Main | Don't worry, keep knitting »

March 19, 2008

Spiraling

The thing about "knitting in the round" is that it's a bit of a misnomer. In actuality, when we knit continuously around an imaginary (or real!) cylinder, we are knitting "in a spiral."

Forgive my stinky-ass diagram. It's certainly better than Plan A: using a drawing of a coil generating a magnetic field, and superimposing stitches on top of it. But it's not quite Plan C: begging TECHknitter to make the diagrams for me (how does she do it?!?).

Anyway, the blue stitches in the back would obviously appear as purl bumps from this angle, but I hope you get the idea.

For those of us familiar with crocheting, the idea that working "in the round" is actually an exercise in "spiraling" is even more evident: sometimes we have to add extra stitches and make other such provisions as we move from one level of the coil to the next.

Not that I would know anything about that particular brand of black magic. Crocheting. Pssshhh!!! Nope, not here.

Our brains are forced to do a little bit of gymnastics as soon as we decide to add a stripe to our "knit in the round" project. Take any circular segment of the spiral, and you will realize that it doesn't close on itself. The beginning and end are not in the same plane - one is higher than the other!

There are many ingenious techniques for hiding "the jog" when colors are changed while working in the round. But that's not what I'm getting at here. In your three-dimensional mind, imagine two coils traveling around the same imaginary cylinder. If we're talking about knit stitches of fixed height, the pitch of each coil doubles as they swirl in parallel.

And each coil can be a different color. And there can be more than two! And round and round each will travel, entirely continuously, without any jog, forming stripes of different colors.

- - - - - - -

I first came across the notion of Helix stripes in Montse Stanley's Knitter's Handbook eons and eons ago. She writes:

Helix stripes

A truly ingenious way of avoiding steps at the start of the rounds and having to carry yarns at back of work, when knitting one-row stripes in circular knitting.

Divide the work into as many, roughly equal, groups of stitches as colors you want to use. Either put each group on its own double-pointed needle, or use needle markers if working with a circular needle. Work 1st group in 1st color, 2nd group in 2nd color, etc.

Work next round similarly, but using the colors as they come - 1st group with last color from previous round, 2nd group with 1st color, etc. Repeat. If working in this way right from the start, cast on each group in a different color.

I accidentally "fell into" the genius of this technique when designing the Art Deco beret. I was using two balls of yarn - one with beads, and one without - and had to alternate them on every round. Somewhere my "twist the yarns in the back to avoid holes" went wrong, and I was suddenly spiraling! Knit one round, pick up the other yarn, knit another round, pick up the first, and so on. Helix stripes à la Montse! No jogs, no holes, no twisting, nothing. Nothing! No tangling, either, since the yarns travel above and below one another, never across. It was so cool.

And what a clever, clever way to use up leftover sock yarn! Perfect stripes, no jogs, and the color combinations are endless.

Do you now see why I referred to the way I knit socks as a determinant of the number of colors I would choose from my pile? Since I love to use 5 dpns, it makes sense to use 4 different colors! Of course I could use more or fewer... or even two balls of the same color one right after the other for a double-thick stripe... but I'm getting ahead of myself here :).

Although I was leaning towards the pinks and reds at first, I decided to use the combination of natural, lilac, navy, and blackberry for these socks. I've weighed the yarn I'm using, and will definitely let you know how much of each color gets eaten up. This information is as much for my benefit as anything, since my navy leftovers are quite limited and I want to make sure I don't run out. Or maybe the second sock will stripe lilac, blackberry, and white... only three colors. That would be quite comical!

The pattern itself is basic - CO 66 sts with blackberry, work K4, P2 ribbing for 20 rounds, divide sts into groups of 16 or 17 and start the spiral! A short-row heel and plain toe will follow, also in worked in blackberry.

In the photo above, can you see where I started the lilac and natural spirals?

Posted by Kathy on March 19, 2008 03:44 PM

Comments

Stashbuster spirals! Can't wait to see how you get on before I jump on board.

Oh, cool! Y'know, since you're "manually" striping, and not using any fixed stripeyness of a single yarn, I bet you could work a gusset heel and maintain the striping. Hmm... *goes to ogle the solid color fingering weight yarns she has kicking around*

Wow! I never would have thought of that.

Brilliant! I had never heard of helix stripes. Now I need to find a striped project to try it on.

Aha, how interesting! I think this is a post my mathematician husband could appreciate, too :)

This is almost creepy! Just last night, I was trying to think up good jogless joins. This is a great idea, and I can't wait to try it out.

woah. So deceptively simple, almost like an illusion. More pictures please as you progress!

Thanks for sharing this great technique! I'm alternating between two skeins for a sleeve I'm knitting now, and I think this method would be a lot easier than switching every two rows as I've been doing.
I'm excited to see how the socks look when they are complete! The color combination will surely be very cute and a great way to use up all of those leftovers.

Genius!!!!!! Absolute genius!!!!!!!!
I love reading your blog - you always have such wonderful techniques to show and I learn so much. Thank you!!!!!!
I have to go scope out my solid colour yarns to see what I can try this with.
I can't wait to get started!!!
(and I love your colour combination!)
Nancy

That is a very cool technique, even though it took me a little to figure out what you meant. I'll have to try it out some time... when I have a great deal more stash to bust than I have now. >.

That is so cool. I have been planning some leftover socks for a while now, and I think that is how I am going to do them!

Freaky! I can't wait to see more, and to try it out myself. Things always make more sense when I get my hands in there to try it out.

Ouch!! I think maybe I sprained my brain thinking aboout this. I will have to get out some needles and give it a try.

So smart, and so simple! Love it.

So cool. I am pulling put some left over yarn to try right now.
Thanks. :)

Hmmm....I'm still not quite 'getting it'. I think I'll re-read this post tomorrow with fresh eyes. Hopefully while I sleep tonight my brain will work it out :-D

This is uber-neat. I want to create a striped project now.

OT, but "round vs spiral" reminds me of a conversation I had during my postdoc interview when the PI talked about "tiled arrays" and drew a diagram showing overlapping probes for a given sequence. Me, not knowing when to shut my mouth, pointed out that tiles don't actually overlap when you lay them on a floor or whatever, and that "tiled" was perhaps not the most accurate descriptor. Heh.

You're blowing my mind, but it feels good. Seeing your picture of an actual sock with the new color starts makes Montse's directions much clearer to me. Good for you!

I don't really get it either, because you still have jogs, but not lined up. Right? Or am I missing something?

Maybe I should just try it on my own before sharing with the class ...

I was actually just trying to work this technique into a project the other day and couldn't quite wrap my brain around how to start it.
Thank you so much!

awesome. thanks for sharing and those socks are amazing!

If you'd like, ask me next time, but I think your diagrams were perfectly serviceable. Nice exposition of helices, thanks.

Yes, technically their are a few "jogs" - specifically, at the very start of each spiral. BUT - that's only four jogs, in opposition to the jog we'd get at the beginning of every row using the joining technique.

Now, I'm imagining using this technique with two balls of a self-striping yarn, starting from opposite ends :)

Now that my brain has stopped hurting, and I read your blog 47 times, I totally get it!! LOL I really want to try this!

yup. that is my brain you see splattered in your email box... but i think I get it - very cool... love your diagrams!

You are one uber l33t geek! And isn't it cool that Montse Stanley is, too? (Is? Was? Off to wikipedia to check.)

Thanks for throwing light on this method!

Helices. Now that is one elegant word, techknitter! :-)

Sorry to clog the comments --

Montse Stanley's brief biography on the Knitting History site:
http://www.knittinghistory.co.uk/montsestanley.html

Rats, she's no longer with us. I bet she'd have loved blogs and ravelry.

Weird. I *think* I get it on the many color example. I'm having a more difficult time wrapping my mind around it on just a 2 color example. It seems it's as simple as offsetting where the colors start...but then my mind says, "how could that possibly work?".

I will have to try it before I'll believe that I have it right (or wrong)!

I knitted a sweater (short sleeved raglan) with 5 colors, in 1-row stripes. the jogs were driving me nuts until my mathematician husband (who used to crochet hats all the time) helped me figure out the spiral thing. It came out great, except there was a mega-jog at the start and end. But, apparently you can space that out by casting on with (or joining) the colors equally around the circle... cool, thanks for the exploration!

Like Kate, I don't get it! Maybe my brain is fried by the activities of the day. I'll try again tomorrow because I was just trying to figure out how to do this for a kid's sweater I'm making. Ended up working the sleeves back & forth instead of magic looping them because I couldn't figure out a way to avoid the jog (and it would have been seriously ugly in this little sweater). Thanks, Kathy.

Wowzers. I've been wanting to make striped socks but the idea of all the jogs was discouraging me. Now I can't wait to try this. (Thanks for adding another project to the never-ending queue :-)

I think I am starting to get it. At first, it sounded to me like you would have the colors alternated across the needle, but, after reading through for a second time, I think you are saying that the colors are in groups on the needles. I have been trying different techniques for the jogless stripe and I usually have a small amount of warping or loose stitches. This looks great!

Excellent! I sort of wondered if this was what you were hinting at, so it's neat to see that it is. I'm currently doing a pair of helical socks myself, but mine are three strands of chocolate brown and one strand of a really brilliant turqoise, with turqoise toes, heels, and cuffs.

Oh.. I've done this before and have been meaning to make a pair of socks using up all my scraps from dyeing in this way. I think they should end up pretty spectacular. I can't wait to see how yours look!

Ooh super clever, thanks for sharing the details

After reading this, I had to immediately dig out four colors of yarn and give this a try. So cool! Thanks for giving us this explanation.

This is pure genius!

Now that I do like. I evidently do have the mind of a mathematician (always knew, deep down, it was a mistake to major in History!) ~x~

I used this technique when I did my Helix Hat. You can see pictures and directions on my blog at
http://joanknits.blogspot.com/2005/11/helix-striped-cap.html. It's great fun!

More diagrams, please. I'm new at this. Sounds absolutely fascinating.

You just blew my mind.
I'm having a little trouble visualizing this tech. Do you know of any online videos?

That's pretty cool...Thanks for sharing!

I get it!! Brilliant! I love Montse Stanley. I have to pull that book out more often. I've got to play with that a bit to see how things look when you get it going--but once going, I can see it will work beautifully.

I'm FASCINATED! I often want to work striped socks...but carrying the colors or weaving in the ends has always seemed like way too much work. This is ingenious...I can't wait to see the results (and then copy your genius for my own benefit. :))

That is the coolest thing I've seen all week. Thanks!

I love it! I must plan some fun stripey socks now. Yours are lovely.

This sounds really cool, but it also sounds like like something that would be easier to try (and thus figure it out) than to think about and logic your way through.

I have tons of sock yarn leftovers, but I am using them for a blanket. Maybe the next time around (after the blanket is done) I'll try this.

That is an excellent, excellent idea. I'm definitely trying this technique out next time I knit stripes!

Oh my gosh. I've had the idea of "spiraling stripes" kicking around in the back of my head for years but never figured out how to actually accomplish it! Thank you so much for this post!

LOL!! I 'discovered' this many years ago when a guild member brought in a pattern for a "Helix Hat". I've made quite a few to use up stash yarns :) In fact, it might be a great idea to 'fix' some pooling issues with some STR...one strand from each end....Mmmm.....never done it with socks as I usually want something more involved....

Holy cow. I think I have an inkling of how Zeus felt when Athena started wiggling her toes. In his brain.

Thanks for explaining it so clearly and elegantly!

very cool Kathy

Dang, I thought you were going to do some stranded something.

Lovely colors, though, and nice idea for the jogless spirals.

Ingenious! And the color combination you've chosen is beautiful. :)

Have you thought of weighing the navy and only using half of it on the first sock. Sock legs don't have to match sock feet, but it usually looks better if legs match legs and feet match feet.

Holy Schmitt! You ARE a genius. This is the first time ever I want to bother with the no jog idea! YEAH!

By far the coolest way to make stripes I've yet seen! Makes me want to bust out different yarns and give it a go! :)

I just had one of those lightbulb moments. This is so clever! *You* are so clever. And I am actually feeling quite clever myself, right now, for finally understanding how this works! Stripey socks here I come baby! Thanks so much Kathy for posting this :)

For years I've been using Meg Swansen's Jogless Jog method but this seems much more interesting and offers more possibilities...This really is brilliant. Thanks...I can't wait to finish up my currents socks to try this. I love Lorna's Laces too!! And I also happen to have Montse's book...I'm all set!

Thank you for this explanation! It has made stripes in the round a much happier experience for me. See my first attempt here:

To cut down on spam, comments are moderated. You may not see your comment right away, but rest assured that it's been received and will appear shortly. Comments are closed a few days after posting.